Yesterday, I left the IRS
office having brought myself into “compliance” so that they would lift the levy
from my bank account and allow me to continue living off of the money I’ve earned…oh,
and so they wouldn’t send me to prison (no, not writing this from North Korea –
I’m in North America).
The staff person who worked with me was the same
sweet woman who was working with me when I took my big, dramatic stand about
two weeks ago. I have to give her credit
for being a very decent human being. She
even showed me the Schedule M for the 2009 and 2010 returns which saved me
$800. I have no complaints against the
woman personally or professionally.
She did, however, leave me with some confusing
marching orders as I left the office. She
said she had to get her manager’s approval to lift the levy, but to go ahead
and call the 800 number on the Notice of Levy I'd received in the mail and have them lift it. “It should be no problem,” she said.
So, leaving some time for that manager to get back
to her and approve everything, I waited until today just after lunch to call
and see if the levy could be lifted. I
had a rather strange conversation with a woman on the phone who said the
manager still hadn’t approved lifting the levy, but that she could grant a “partial”
lifting. She asked if I had any pressing
needs “right now,” so I thought of the most current need, which was that I
probably had a couple phone bills past due because they froze the assets in my
account. She asked a few other questions
about my current income, and I thought I made it pretty clear that my current
income is about half of my current living expenses, and that I need what was in
the bank to make up the difference until my tuning business is back on its
feet. She put me on hold, and when she got
back to me she said she was releasing $300 from the levy. I thanked her (sincerely) and said that if
that was all she was able to do, I might have to go back to the office and see
if they might try to reach that manager soon as Friday was the day my frozen
assets would be automatically turned over to the IRS if the levy wasn’t lifted.
I thought as I shared this idea that the lady would
give a sort of “That’s probably a good idea considering your circumstances”
reply, and we’d be done. Instead, she
started getting upset with me and telling me that the IRS only lifts levies if
they feel there are extenuating circumstances.
I explained that I thought next month’s rent and child support payments
were pressing enough to warrant it, and that without what I had in the bank
being made available, my current income would not be able to meet my normal monthly
expenses. Somehow – somehow, my friends,
she couldn’t grasp this and remained upset with me that I would still try to
get the entire levy lifted. We had
rather a terse goodbye, and I was rushing back to the IRS office only an hour
before I was supposed to pick up my youngest son from school.
I reached the office in good time and approached the
lady at the service desk. I explained
that I had been in yesterday getting my ducks in a row to get a levy lifted and
that some manager needed to give their approval before the Friday deadline or I’d
lose what they had levied.
“Well, there are no managers at this office,
sir. You’ll just have to wait for one of
them to call the woman who was helping you yesterday.”
“Yes. I just
thought if I could talk to her again today and see if we might put in another
call to that manager.” A line was
beginning to form behind me, and there were others already seated and waiting
to speak with an assistant.
“There’s really nothing we can do right now, sir.”
“Well, I need that money to live on and Friday is
the deadline. I can’t lose that money.”
“She put in the call yesterday, so now all we can do
is wait.”
“I’m only making half of what I need every month to get
by, so I need that money I brought back from my deployment to make up the
difference. I’m trying to rebuild my
business.”
“Sir, she put in the call- “
“But I thought maybe another phone call because of
the deadline. You know, the squeaky
wheel and all that. Well, I guess I’ll
just have to hold my breath.”
“Oh, I wouldn’t do that!” she kidded.
I smiled, but I felt sick inside. Why do I have to fight for money I’ve
rightfully earned? I’ve harmed no one or
their property, yet I’m treated like a criminal. I’m begging for the use of my own money.
“Sir, wait right here a moment,” she said. She went and got the woman I worked with
yesterday, who assured me that as soon as she heard from the manager she would
call me. I thanked her and left.
A couple hours later, she called and gave me the
good news as I was going to pick up my other boy. The entire levy should be lifted some time
tomorrow. It felt good to hear, and I
sincerely thanked her for her help.
I still feel grateful, but let’s not get all
sentimental, okay? A runaway slave can
feel genuine gratitude for being spared the whip as a “just” punishment for
running away, but don’t mistake his or her feeling of gratitude for a wholesale
acceptance of the institution of slavery.
The runaway taxpayer is back on the plantation, in his proper place, but
he still resents the fact that he continues to live under the same threat of
punishment that he just avoided. A
compliant slave with a scar-free back is no less a slave than the rebellious one being whipped.
Two weeks ago I told the IRS to stuff it, and then
spent the next three days facing the very real possibilities of what that could
mean. The only other time I’ve felt so
oppressed and distraught over the future was when I had visitation with my boys
cut to almost nothing overnight for no justifiable reason. That wasn’t just threatened – that happened. It sucked the life right out of me. I remember laying on my couch in a ball –
helpless, hopeless, my insides churning with real grief and despair. It’s a feeling I genuinely wouldn’t wish on
my worst enemies. And so these threats
from the IRS – confiscation of property and rights to property, imprisonment –
went to work on my mind and heart and caused the same emotional trauma as the assault
on my visitation. The common denominator
between the two situations was the lack
of necessity. That’s the part that
kills you. “None of this is necessary,
yet it’s happening (or very well could happen).”
So, I’m in “compliance,” the levy is to be lifted,
and I’m allowed to carry on almost as if nothing happened. I’m back in “my place” as a taxpayer. Where does this leave me from two weeks ago
when I “got my rebel on”?
One word: determined.
Kurt, somehow this post really got me to grasp your thesis about how monstrously unfair and demeaning the income tax is. The scene of you standing before faceless, uncaring bureaucrats begging for access to your own money just illustrates your whole point more clearly and vividly than anything else you've written. I definitely get your sense of injustice that you have to go through this humiliation, especially when, as you've argued and I've conceded, this is all completely unnecessary. If there were no income tax, there would be no IRS, no audits, no levies, none of it.
ReplyDeleteBut still, I get the feeling that there's an untold story here, another side of things that maybe needs to be revealed. Maybe you need to "come clean," and tell the whole story about how this whole situation came into being. I can't imagine it just sprang up out of nowhere; it has to have been building up over time. Maybe you don't want go into all of that in a public forum, and I can certainly understand that. But I do think some context would be helpful.
Hey, happy to "come clean," as it were. For the fuller picture, you and anyone reading this can go to the homepage for this blog (or is it the first post?). In any case, there's a link to a free e-book I've written on this subject ("A Question of Liberty"), and the Prologue of the book tells how this saga began. I suppose anyone coming to the blog and starting right here would be sure to have some questions.
DeleteThe short version here would be my getting a rather hefty tax bill the year after I took over another tuner's business (he moved out of state). That bill got me to thinking and studying and researching, and I guess you could say that I actually took my stand against this tax when I decided to just stop paying it - this was six years ago. I had a long and fruitless correspondence with the IRS during this time - wrote to them, the Illinois Department of Revenue, my state and federal representatives, and the President, asking all of them how the income tax does NOT diminish my right to earn a living to a privilege (if the right is to be exercised in any meaningful way, and free of any burden or control other than respecting the rights of others). Fruitless. There was another levy issued a few years ago, and I do remember telling the IRS rep on the phone that I couldn't do this anymore, and that, rather than paying the tax, I was trying to figure out how to abolish it. The lady on the phone wished me luck on my journey! It may have been sarcasm, but I didn't detect any. That was memorable. So, it's really been six years of protesting and asking questions and researching.
So then this levy hit, and I decided to tell someone at the IRS face-to-face that I was done. Then I caved under the pressure as I pondered the possible consequences, and here we are.