"Tax season" is upon us. Time to get excited about that anticipated refund or some company's fast and/or free service! Look closely at the people in these ads - this is how we're supposed to be feeling.
If your feelings aren't reflected here, there is something wrong with you. You must be one of those selfish right-wingers who hate poor people and think only of themselves. You must think that the bells and whistles of civilization don't cost anything. You must be one of those scary anarchist people who live in the hills and belong to a militia. Shame on you for not caring about the lower classes, for hating powerful, centralized, bloated government. Shame on you for not knowing your patriotic duty. Or...
Perhaps your feelings aren't reflected here because you no longer subscribe to the notion that the income tax is the "fairest" system we've come up with. Perhaps you realize that the only reason people aren't rushing into the poorest neighborhoods of their cities to extol the virtues of the income tax is because there is nothing to be said. A tax that was sold to the public as the answer to the rich paying their fair share, that would lessen the gap between rich and poor...well? It's been a full century now. Still waiting. When do all those good things kick in? Do we give it another 100 years, like naive 4-year-olds who believe Santa's sleigh will actually be landing on their roof on Christmas Eve? Or can we be adults about this and pull the plug?
These people are happy and smiling because they don't see the connection between the income tax and the Robber Baron crowd who literally wrote the legislation to get it off the ground. I promise you, it isn't the poor who would moan and groan if the income tax were to be abolished. It's the uber-wealthy who would shit their pants. The income tax is their gravy train, it lines their pockets, it maintains their insanely rich lifestyles, it allows for a huge military-industrial complex, it is corporate welfare. And it is all these things by design. It's not that our income tax money is being misallocated - no. It's going where it was meant to go - to the wealthy. When the man who literally wrote the book on why the income tax was being championed a hundred years ago admits that it wasn't needed for revenue purposes, that everything that needed to be paid for by government was already being handled by taxes on foreign goods and a few articles produced here (with a surplus in the Treasury to boot, and without putting people in the Poor House), then why would we fail to suspect that this unnecessary revenue that was going to be raised would end up anywhere other than in the pockets of the Robber Barons who launched the system, and their heirs?
Remember, the tax system that was in place worked so well it created a surplus, and it wasn't responsible for creating the lower class. The lower class was already there, and already (and understandably) complaining of their situation. The income tax system was pitched in a way that sympathized with the poor; it was pushed as a remedy to their plight. (Ever heard of politicians pandering to their constituents, and all the while scheming to line their own pockets and the pockets of their true supporters? Look it up - it's happened before.) Of course Congress would approve it. "Soak the rich!" was the rallying cry behind the income tax. It all sounds so good, so right, so noble. But in terms of government revenue, in terms of meeting the government's operating costs, the income tax was to raise a surplus on top of a surplus. Nothing suspicious there at all.
Yeah, believing that Santa was going to visit my house on Christmas Eve used to bring a big smile to my face. I gotta hand it to you - you folks who still believe in the income tax are the true optimists, the true believers. Smile!
Thursday, February 7, 2013
Tuesday, February 5, 2013
Letter To The Louisiana Governor
January 11, 2013
From: Kurt Henning
Illinois
Illinois
To: Governor Bobby Jindal
Office of the Governor
Baton Rouge, LA 70804
Office of the Governor
Baton Rouge, LA 70804
Dear Governor Jindal,
I am writing from the
State of Illinois because I have recently learned that you are considering
eliminating the state income tax in Louisiana.
I wish to express that, as a student of American taxation for the last
seven years, I am heartily in favor of such a move for the people of your
State.
The news media reports
that you feel the citizens should be able to have more of the money they have
earned in their pockets. I agree, and I
am sure that many of your fellow citizens feel the same way. I am also sure you realize that your State
would become the tenth in the Union that currently meets its expenses without a
tax on the income of its citizens. This would
mean that one out of every five of our States have learned they can get along
without an income tax. This is progress!
As well as expressing
my support for what you are considering, I would also like to respectfully
suggest something as you and your supporters strive to make this significant,
positive change. I would ask that you
consider what you are doing in light of every human being’s fundamental right
to earn a living, and that a tax on one’s earned income essentially reduces
that right to a privilege.
I believe that one’s
right to earn a living deserves heightened protection from any burdens laid
upon it for two reasons: 1. Because it is primarily through the exercise of
this right that we are even able to enjoy our right to live, and 2. Because
this right is, in and of itself, one of the primary responsibilities of any
adult member of society. Most rights
that we recognize are exercised at one’s discretion. There are a few rights that we are compelled
to exercise as they are among the most basic of human responsibilities. Among the rights of this nature are the right
to work, the right of self-defense, and the right to parent our children. Some might argue that buying food is a
responsibility, and so by the same token should not be taxed. But working
for our living is the wellspring that makes buying the necessities and
comforts of life possible, and so deserves that extra measure of protection
from being burdened in any way. No one
should be incurring debt as they strive
to meet their basic human responsibility of earning a living.
As part of my studies,
I have written letters to the governors of all nine states that currently levy
no tax on income. The letters were to
simply ask why. The five responses I
received basically came down to economic reasons – that it was economically
viable to do away with that form of taxation, and so they did. I have come to believe that there are more
important reasons to avoid a tax on earned income – matters of principle, as
stated above. A California commission
reported in 1906 on the question of whether or not to introduce a state income
tax: “The Commission believes that it would not be wise to take advantage of
this section [of the State constitution which permits an income tax]…Our people
have so much respect for labor that what is won by honest toil is regarded as
sacred and not to be reduced by direct taxation.” It is that respect for a person’s labor that
I believe needs to be restored in this country.
As your State can easily prove, and as nine others are proving every
day, there are other ways, there are other means.
I wish your endeavor
all success, Governor. I hope that it
will raise awareness in this country that we are not stuck with the income tax
– it is optional. Most have been taught
their entire lives that it is absolutely necessary, inevitable, and eternal,
and therefore never look below the surface at the deeper implications of such a
form of taxation. Some still actually
cling to the notion that an income tax is the Great Equalizer for society. After 100 years (of the federal income tax),
we are all still holding our breath waiting for that to happen.
Thank you for your
service to your great State, and for considering what a neighbor from afar has
to say. Though we are of different
States, I take great interest in this subject because I believe that what you
and the other nine States do in regard to taxation can have very positive
implications for the entire nation.
Best wishes to you and to the people of Louisiana.
Sincerely,
[signed]
Kurt Henning
Illinois, USA
Wednesday, January 30, 2013
An Open Letter To A Liberal Friend, Part 3 (of 3)
At one time I believed that the “natural state of
man” meant a guy out in the wilderness, all alone. No laws or rules to follow, no
accountability, perfect freedom from control and regulation. Just a guy fighting the elements to stay
alive for as long as he can.
I’ve come to see that nothing could be further from
the truth. Man is a social creature by nature – his natural state is one of
mingling with his own kind. The loner
out in the wilderness is being led by an instinct that is something other than human. He is more akin to the male leopard (mating
season notwithstanding). Well, so long
as Wild Man is hurting no one, I wish him every success out there.
Meanwhile, there’s a heap of us constantly rubbing
elbows and trying to get along. Isn’t it
funny that we even have to try, given
our social nature? And that is what
separates us from, say, a herd of water buffalo (mating season
notwithstanding). Friction between
humans, who are naturally social, speaks to the reality of the individual.
I taught preschool for 15 years and recall a saying
we had among the staff: “We know children, you know your child.” It spoke to the facts that we, the Early
Childhood educators, were experts on children in general, and that nobody knew an individual child better than the
parents. This view of things made it
very easy for the staff to work with parents in a team effort to meet the needs
of an individual child; to help the parents see us as a resource for them, and
to remind the staff that the parents of a particular child were the real
experts on that child. Combining general knowledge of people with very specific knowledge of a person seemed to be the most effective way to deal with any
issues a child was dealing with. In the
end, the key to a happy, harmonious room full of 2- and 3-year-olds came down
to dealing with and respecting each child as an individual. The Quacker Room was a very happy place, and
its teachers were very tired and underpaid, but on the ball.
I believe the collectivist/individualist conflict is
an unnecessary one, because it paints people as being one way or the other
(lone individuals or a member of a herd), yet we are neither, because we are
both. I think it goes back to what I
said in the last post: who do we fear the most?
The assholes who run the government, or the assholes who run the
corporations? I say, fear them all! Why leave some of the assholes out? Why be biased? Regulate them all!
When the Left calls for regulation of the banks and
corporations and the Right calls for limited government (which is just another
term for regulation), what are they really asking for? Protection.
Protection for…people. So, the
motivation for these calls for protection comes from compassion, from
charitable hearts. It’s people caring
about other people – on both sides of the political spectrum.
There is no reason that a call for limited
government must go hand-in-hand with finding the poor to be despicable and
undeserving of help. In fact, many who
espouse limited government follow a religion that gave birth to the concepts of
hospitals, full-time charitable organizations, orphanages, and universities (if
my research serves me well). They are
some of the most hospitable and charitable people I have ever met, who have, if
anything, a soft spot for the poor. Bear
in mind I’m talking about people I have met personally. These are real people. I’ve seen in the media the same cold-hearted,
self-centered Right that you have, but I’ve never run across those
people in real life. I suppose they’re
out there, but my guess is that they are the minority. I suppose there might be some reason that the
media and politicians would want to magnify that crowd…I don’t know…some reason. As cynical as I am, I still believe in the
basic goodness of people.
Though you know I have left the Christian religion,
I will borrow a teaching from it that I believe we should apply to government
and big business alike, and if we don’t, we will pay a heavy price. Jesus posed the question: “Was Man made for
the Sabbath, or the Sabbath made for Man?” The problem with big government, as is the problem
with big business, is that what began as something created by humans ostensibly
to serve other humans can become something that humans are eventually forced to serve. When this happens, something very fundamental
has surely been turned on its head (see: world history).
When enough individuals start to feel like their purpose in life is to work for, fund,
and be accountable to their government, then that government’s days are
numbered. No one experiences life as “a
group.” Each one experiences their own
life as an individual. He may share
experiences with others, but he lives those experiences within himself. Corporations would reduce us to a faceless
mob whose sole purpose is to produce for the corporation. Governments (which are corporations, after
all) have the same tendency, and we must not lose sight of that fact. And when governments prevail in turning their
citizens into one giant sweatshop, the results are never prosperity for the
poor, peace, and harmony. It’s just the
opposite.
As I said at the outset, these are the ramblings of
THIS libertarian, neither on the Right nor the Left. I’m sure I’ve left some holes in what I’ve
been trying to share, and I apologize if I haven’t delivered something that is
worth thinking about, as I had hoped.
I’ll try to sum it all up by saying that I happen to
think we (the general population) are naturally
united in our humanity, that we are naturally
compassionate and charitable, and that it is the self-centered interests who we
allow to run the show that artificially
divide us and preoccupy us and weaken us, who show us the dreaded face of the
fanatical, cold-hearted Right and the smug self-righteousness of the godless
Left with no moral compass. If we could
all just move the curtain to the side and look past the smoke and mirrors, I
think we would all see a bunch of super rich bastards pushing buttons and
pulling levers and holding shiny objects in front of us, mesmerizing us and
causing us to walk through life in a stupor as, in the words of George Carlin,
“obedient workers.” Did I say I was
cynical?
Monday, December 31, 2012
On Guns
I did not grow up within a strong “gun culture” – my
experiences with guns were few and far between. Having been a Navy Reservist
now for nine years, I am qualified (according to Navy standards) to handle the
9mm pistol, and I have been associating with people who did grow up within a strong “gun culture.” I have found the large
majority of them to be what I would consider “good people” – kind, considerate,
respectful.
Our highly safety-conscious military has extremely
strict rules as to who will carry firearms and when, and how and where those
firearms will be stowed when not in use. Literally every weapon, magazine, and
bullet is accounted for. The first thing you see when you go to the armory to
clean your weapon is a sign in big, red letters: USE OF DEADLY FORCE IS
AUTHORIZED. They are not messing
around in the armory – if they see you doing something irresponsible and
potentially hazardous with your weapon, they will take you down (as a last
resort). Safety first.
It occurs to me that if our military has such strong
weapons regulations and accountability for our own soldiers and sailors, and
given that generally everyone in the military recognizes these regulations as a
matter of common sense and safety, then why shouldn’t we expect such regulation
on the largely untrained civilian population? Are safety and accountability necessarily in conflict with rights and liberty?
Guns are very dangerous. They are lethal. I would
think that a thoughtful, freedom-loving population would see it as being in
everyone’s best interest to bring a few more responsibilities to bear on any
civilian’s right to own a gun. I think we’re all okay with the concept of
“rights and responsibilities.” It just makes sense.
I need to call on my military and “gun culture”
friends to fall back on their training. We know “Improvise. Adapt. Overcome.”
Well, we have a situation here. Something’s changed in our society, and there
will be time to figure it out eventually. Right now, we need to come together
as trained professionals who, as human beings, love our fellow human beings
more than political rhetoric. Our children, our civilian population – they need
us to toss out, not the Constitution, but the political rhetoric that seems to
shut down communication, the sharing of ideas.
We need to Improvise some new rhetoric that keeps
channels of communication open, moving beyond “from my cold, dead hands!” I
don’t even know what the new rhetoric will be – that’s why they call it improv.
We need to Adapt – we don’t know with certainty
what’s caused the change in society that is wreaking this havoc on us, but we
know change has occurred, so we must adapt to that change now and not wait
until we “figure it out.” We have a situation. Children are being slaughtered,
and have been for too long in our schools, malls, neighborhoods, streets, and
homes.
We need to Overcome. No more of this. No more.
I believe the regulation and accountability we
accept as trained professionals in weapons handling is based on common sense
and common safety, and we would be irresponsible to not insist upon it for our
untrained civilian population. It’s the same irresponsibility as allowing
untrained, unlicensed electricians to wire our homes. As with anything useful
but potentially lethal, we need guidelines, standards, and accountability to
reduce risk as much as possible. In the case of guns, we’re talking about
regulation, strict accountability, and, above all, access.
Friday, December 7, 2012
An Open Letter To A Liberal Friend, Part 2
If we can agree that everyone at every point of the
political spectrum has their humanity in common, then we can expect common
behaviors that spring from that fact.
Probably the number one behavior common to all
people is that of self-preservation.
Virtually everything we do relates directly or indirectly to maintaining
life. Why do we work? To earn money. What do we buy with that money? Food, shelter, clothing. Why do we desire those things? Because they help us sustain our lives.
Aside from natural disasters, disease, or old age,
what is it that can most interfere with our efforts to sustain our lives and to
pursue our own happiness during the short time we are here? To put it bluntly, assholes. And, aside from the generic street thug
assholes running around, which assholes pose the greatest threat to our lives
and happiness? The ones in power. And where are the seats of power in
society? Government, business, and
religion.
This is why separation of church and state is
desirable – to limit the power of religious authority over civil society. This is why the Left wants business regulated
– to limit the power and influence of Big Business over the lives of the common
worker. This is why the Right wants
small government – to limit bureaucratic power over the lives of the average
citizen.
It’s a cryin’ shame that, with few exceptions, “humans
+ power” tends to lead those who find themselves in positions of power to yield
to their Inner Asshole. What do people
with power want? Again, with few
exceptions, they want their power to be secure, and they want more power. This makes them, in the eyes of their fellow
human beings who feel they have little or no power, assholes. And this will always be true regardless of
time or place: no one wants their life run (and potentially ruined) by an
asshole. Self-preservation. It’s instinctual.
Everyone wants the powerful assholes they fear the
most to be limited in their
power. “Government regulation” is the
Left’s answer to keeping the assholes who run things in the private sector in
check. “Limited government,” or
government held in place by the “chains of the Constitution,” is the Right’s
answer to checking the power of the assholes who run the government. It’s the same response to the same fear. It seems to be a question of what we fear the
most.
In this one short paragraph, I can prove that both
sides have legitimate concerns. Do you
think we have nothing to fear from leaders in the private sector? Work in or just visit a sweatshop. Do you think we have nothing to fear from government? Look at the Third Reich. Look at Stalin. Think of the millions of souls who would
scream from their early graves if they could: Beware out-of-control
government! Beware captains of industry
who are not held accountable!
The Left and Right would do themselves a favor if
they would stop looking at each other and pointing fingers and engaging in
constant friction, and realize their common goal: to hold accountable the
Assholes In Charge – all of them.
In the next (and last) part, I will share my
thoughts on humans as individuals and as parts of a whole, and hopefully
bolster my ultimate position that there is far more that unites us than divides. Thanks for reading, my friend.
Sunday, December 2, 2012
An Open Letter To A Liberal Friend, Part 1
I am writing this post as an open letter to a
particular friend of mine so that, while addressing him as an individual, I can
hopefully bring a “teachable moment” to the masses who daily cling to every
word of this blog for knowledge and guidance (hey, I don’t mind making myself
the butt of a joke). :)
Also, when I speak of the libertarian perspective, I
mean THIS libertarian.
________________________
Dear Friend,
I am happy to learn that you have an open mind and
are at least willing to listen to what I have to say. Our subject is an old one: whether people
should view the needs of society from the individual or collectivist point of
view. You place yourself firmly on the
side of the collectivists and have said that, in order to adopt my
individualist philosophy, you “would need to know the mercy and kindness in it,
rather than the callous indifference and self-centeredness that is apparent on
its face.”
I’m glad you said, “…that is apparent on its
face.” If you’ve read much of this blog,
you will know that I am definitely in favor of looking below the surface of
things. When I last wrote you, I
suggested that “we are more of kindred spirits than you may believe when it
comes to caring about other people.”
To generalize, I am typically viewed as a
libertarian, and you are viewed as a liberal.
One point we can agree on and boast about is the fact that we view
liberty as belonging to every person equally.
We do not see liberty as something we dole out only to people who look,
believe, or behave as we do. We accept
diversity and do not discriminate where the enjoyment of liberty is
concerned. “Freedom” is the root of our
party names, and we take to heart the idea that “all men [people] are created
equal,” and should therefore enjoy freedom on an equal footing. We also recognize that, unfortunately, it has
not been played out as such on the world stage.
But this has not caused us to give up on the idea!
“Individualism” has been given a bad name by many of
the people who espouse it. To those on
the left side of the political spectrum, the philosophies coming from the right
can look very callous and self-centered.
Libertarians themselves have also been known to shoot individualism in
the foot. I recently had a conversation
with one who had a problem with me saying that “liberty is for the common
good.” He wouldn’t accept “the common
good” because it smacked of collectivist ideology. He said that liberty went beyond the common
good and was essential for humanity’s very existence. I replied that nothing says “common” like the
word “humanity,” and that there was no need to fear the word “common” – it does
not contain communist cooties.
There seems to be fear on both sides: the left fears
that the masses will needlessly suffer if we don’t address them as a
whole. The right fears being controlled
by faceless bureaucracies who don’t respect them as individual persons – they fear
being reduced to a cog in the bureaucratic machinery. It is my view that the fears on either side
are legitimate. These fears should not
be discounted or written-off merely as the products of baseless and blind party
ideology. These fears are based on
something that is undeniably common to both sides of the political spectrum:
our shared humanity.
Wednesday, November 14, 2012
Cue Laughter!
You know, it’s humiliating when you really think
about the esteem you are held in by the powers that be.
After all the t-crossing and i-dotting I did at the
IRS office a month ago to get into “compliance,” and agreeing that I would try
to start paying (come December) $50 a month toward the $45,000 they want to
collect from me, I got a letter in the mail from the IRS stating that they want
me to pay over $6,000 immediately for my 2010 taxes. Talk about a buzzkill. Here I was, looking forward to the holidays,
remembering how difficult it was to go through them last year in Kuwait – away from
my boys. But this year, I’ll be putting
up the tree early and leaving it up late, happily scraping together what I can
to light up the boys’ faces when they look under said tree in late December,
and thoroughly soaking up the holiday glow as much as I possibly can.
But the powers that be, first of all, don’t have to
look over their shoulders at past tax liabilities – many of them have none,
because they had no liability to begin with.
We who would “soak the rich” via the income tax are laughed at. As a reminder:
New
York Times, June, 2011: “There are 78,000 tax filers with
incomes of $211,000 to $533,000 who will pay no federal income taxes this year.
Even more amazingly, there are 24,000 households with incomes of $533,000 to
$2.2 million with zero income tax liability, and 3,000 tax filers with incomes
above $2.2 million with the same federal income tax liability as most of those
with incomes barely above the poverty level.”
There are over 100,000 wealthy people who could look
at my tax liability and just laugh it away.
“Ain’t my problem! Sucks to be
Kurt Henning!” And that’s all it would
be to them.
But it’s a lot more than that for me. For me, it’s the year after my deployment
where I get to try to rebuild my business.
It’s the first holiday season back where my business is pulling in about
half of my monthly living expenses and I still must draw on whatever savings I
brought back from my service overseas – savings that will dry up in about three
months if business doesn’t improve soon.
But Uncle Sam is serious about
what I earned in 2010, and the debt I incurred for earning it. “We’ve got to have that six thousand bucks,
Henning! We mean it! We’re depending on you, you American patriot,
you!”
Fuck that.
Fuck the whole income tax system.
I didn’t fall into “compliance” out of a sense of patriotic duty. I’m not complying so little Timmy will have a
school to go to and little Sally’s mommy will have a nice road to drive on. We had all that shit before we had an income
tax. I’m in “compliance” because I don’t
want to have to try raising my children from a prison cell, and I don’t want to give
the IRS the “right” to pull everything I have out of my own bank account. It’s called compulsion, coercion,
extortion. It’s just the legal kind,
which makes me a legal victim – and that makes it all better. But legal and legitimate are not always the
same thing.
So, I’ll march back over to the IRS office and show
them the letter, and I’m sure they’ll say something like, “That letter was
automatically generated. You’ll probably
get one for each year you just filed for.
Don’t worry. We’ll just start
your payment plan in December like we talked about.”
There are over 100,000 very wealthy people who never
have to worry about such letters, who never have to worry about rebuilding
their business after a deployment, who never have to worry about fulfilling the
holiday wishes of their children. And,
somehow, Uncle gets along without their income tax money. No letters, no liability, no worries, no
threats. Must be nice.
And the galling thing is that the difference is
this: those people in Congress who literally write the tax code and send it off
to the government printing press, they hold those wealthy folks in higher
esteem than they do me. I’m easy to look
down upon. I am easy to disrespect. I am easy to exploit. Because I am not one of the wealthy class who
can scratch the backs of the “representatives of the People” [laugh track], I
am just one of the Many who can be milked.
“And they have to let us squeeze their hardworking teats, or we’ll throw
them in prison!” They laugh.
Can you hear them laughing? You signed a W-4 for your job, right? They’re laughing at you, too, sucker.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

